Patti challenges us to show how we crop our shots and why. See her own great examples of how to do here.
There is a vast difference between taking a picture and making a photograph.
– Robert Heinecken
There are different ways to enhance a photo, and I am quite sure many of us use some kind of software to help deliver the feeling we want to shine through to the viewer. One of the easiest ways to change a photo considerably is by cropping it.
”This week’s challenge is a chance to explore a photo editing technique and the benefits of cropping the shot. Show us how cropping helped to improve an image and create a desired effect. Include the shot “before” and “after” so we can see the difference.”
I cannot say I am an avid ”cropper”, but often I do some minor cropping. I am fully aware of the photo losing quality if I crop it too much.
Today I tried to find photos where I could easily show how I think. In the header/opener is a photo from my garden and the magnolia in late evening light. Even if I like that photo, I was not happy about my house showing as a blue ”shadow” in the background. There was also a flare on the upper left hand side. I made a rather tough cropping and the result is only the brightest flower in focus. I still like that first image, but a close-up was my final choice.
A boat trip in Holland last spring went to an outdoor museum, and this is where we landed. I loved the orange and blue together, but the old factory was the main building,
so I cropped out everything on the right side of the photo. This also made the content more substantial. In the first photo, I found the ”division in two parts” disturbing, even if the skies were much more alive and the photo had a lovely ”painterly” feeling.
A final example is from a misty morning walk, where the path is a much loved one, but the image is in more harmony when its focus is far away to the upper right.
This was my final choice. The light green moving towards a darker nuance, instead of being a dividing part in the middle of the photo with darker green in beginning and end.
All in all, it is a good idea to put yourself the question Why should I crop? Because, there should always be a reason. And you always lose something in order to win something else. The goal is to make the first image the final image, but at least for me, it seldom is. I have noticed one thing though – I should trust my first thought/shot. Often I go back to it again – to find it wasn’t that bad…
Next week, we’re delighted to announce that Sue of Mac’s Girl will be our guest host for Lens-Artists Photo Challenge #97 on Saturday, May 16th. Please be sure to stop by her site and join the fun.
This is beautiful!
Thank you, Emmie.
Awesome pics just loving it🤗
Thank you
I love what you’ve done with the cropping. The choice with the buildings – the orange and blue – is perfect (in my eye). The path through the woods crop really does shift the mood. I appreciate the reasoning you explain – and yes, I agree, sometimes the first choice is the one to go with. And sometimes it is just the beginning 🙂
Thank you – glad you appreciated it. It is also fun to get more images than one out of the first photo. You can do so much and create different stories.
You’re welcome. That’s a main reason I enjoy cropping – the different stories!
A good one!
Excellent examples. The crisp color and detail in both the boat shots is stunning. Well done.
Lovely photos Ann Christine.
You have some really nice examples, but I really do like your last final choice photo.
Love how you cropped your photos, Ann-Christine.
Regards, teresa
Thank you so much, Teresa. I find I maybe should crop a bit more often – now that I see all the entries!
Pingback: Lens-Artist-PC-96-Cropping – WoollyMuses
Excellent examples of cropping the shot, Ann-Christine. Although I love both versions of the picture, cropping the boat image really makes it stand out.
Glad you found they are working, and the boat cropping indeed makes a big difference.
Nicely done, shows the power of the tool.
Thank you, Sally.
Beautiful photos!!
Glad you like them!
Wonderful crops, AC. I especially love your first shot of the flower. Beautiful. I also love how you express this: ”And you always lose something in order to win something else.” I also find that it is true, as well as your next thought: ”The goal is to make the first image the final image, but at least for me, it seldom is. I have noticed one thing though – I should trust my first thought/shot. Often I go back to it again – to find it wasn’t that bad…”. For me, that is true. But 99% of the time I have to crop because my shots are usually crooked. 😒😒
glad you liked my thoughts too, Patti – and I must say…when I photograph the sea and a coast line – it is always, always crooked 😦 I don’t know about others, but I am hopeless there.
I’ve decided that my head is crooked. 😊😊
Beautiful images Ann-Christine and I prefer the original of the magnolia too. It has a lovely dreamy feel to it and I liked the little splash of blue 💙 xxx
So happy you liked it, Xenia – so do I, but I could not bear my house peeping through in blue…Thank you!
Nice
Thank you
Nice examples!! I love the boat photo!!
Nora, I loved the colours in that one – glad you liked it too!
Lovely images. I actually like both your cropped and u cropped magnolia image, such lovely light
Thank you – glad you feel the same as I do – I like both.
hi a. c. you have found an interesting selection for the theme, i especially like the last two pictures.
best regards robert
Thank you, Robert, so glad you liked them!
Excellent examples, and I love the back lighting on the flowers. Thanks for posting.
Thank you for a lovely comment! Backlit flowers is a treat, I agree.
Some wonderful examples A-C, especially the second image which really focuses on the point of the image. I must say in the opener I liked the original very much. Perhaps because you knew the blue was a shadow of your home you cropped it out. I thought your magnolia was in front of a distant blue pond 🙂 You are too honest!
Well, I liked that first one too – for the light and mood, but you know…I am an honest person, always. Good or bad. I wish it was a pond…
Great examples Ann-Christine. The first and last definitely are improved by cropping. I understand the crop on the second, but agree that the original photo has merit.
thank you for showing us how to crop and why. the cropped photographs are gorgeous! 🙂
Glad you liked them – sometimes I like both versions and cannot choose which one to use…
Great examples!
Thank you, Sheree!
All are beautifully cropped, A-C. Thank you for showing us how and why for cropping. 🙏💗
Thank you, Amy – it is great fun to see what can be done with cropping a photo!
So interesting to see your cropping choices. They really improve the photos and guide the viewers eye to what is most important in the photo.
Glad you liked them, Anne! The thing is, there are often at least two photos in one…as you could see I crop for different reasons and sometimes I like both!
Good work
Thanks a lot!